Olly Richards from IWillTeachYouALanguage.com
Kris Broholm welcomes Olly Richards from IWillTeachYouALanguage.com. They discuss language learning strategies, focusing specifically on Chinese and Japanese. Olly shares practical advice for listeners interested in learning new languages.
May 23, 2014 · 53 min
EP 11: Olly Richards from IWillTeachYouALanguage.com
0:00 / 52:54
Guest
Olly Richards
What You'll Hear
- 1 Welcome: Guest Olly Richards and Podcast News
- 2 Olly's Journey: From Cafe to Language Learner
- 3 Immersion: Not a Given, Habits are Key
- 4 Why Olly Learned Japanese and Cantonese
- 5 Scripts: Japanese, Chinese, and Learning Strategies
- 6 New Language Strategy: Sprints for Deeper Learning
- 7 Maintaining Languages: It Comes Back, Trust Yourself
Links Mentioned
Questions Covered in the Show
How did Olly Richards start learning languages?- 4m
How important is it to live in a country to learn its language?- 13m
What is the best advice for learning challenging Asian languages like Cantonese or Japanese?- 26m
How should language learners approach learning scripts for Asian languages like Chinese and Japanese?- 28m
What are the main differences between Japanese and Chinese writing systems?- 35m
How do polyglots like Olly Richards stay motivated to learn languages?- 40m
How can language learners prevent their foreign language skills from deteriorating?- 48m
Related Episodes
See all →On this episode of the actual fluency podcast, I'm joined by the man behind I will teach your language.com, Olly Richards. Olly and I talk about language learning and we go into specific details about Chinese and Japanese. Welcome to the actual fluency podcast. The podcast that gives you the tools and inspiration to learn languages faster and more efficiently. And now your host, Chris Broholm.
All right. Welcome to another episode of the actual fluency podcast. As always, I am your host, Chris Broholm. And today, I have a very interesting guest lineup for you guys. It's Olly Richards from I will teach you a language.com. And Olly is one of the people I followed in great detail before I decided to start my own blog. And in terms of inspiration, he definitely delivers. And he also has a lot of specific advice for people who want to learn languages. So I definitely encourage you guys to check out I will teach you a language.com. And it does what it says on the tin.
Now, before we get into the interview, I just want to get a few admin things out of the way. And there aren't that many specific actual fluency news. I'll just go straight to these little announcements. And the first is that actual fluency has been nominated in the category Top Language Lover blogs of 2014. It's a yearly competition that's run by Babbel. And considering that my blog is only from uh I started in February this year. And I was, you know, eagerly following the competition last year, it is incredibly uh humbling for me to already be, you know, nominated in the category. And although I I I'm probably unlikely to win, I'm up against some some amazing blogs, like uh, you know, Lindsey and also Olly's is up there and of course the giant Benny Lewis, but he can't win every year, right? So, uh, you know, all that I ask of you is is, you know, vote for your favorite one and if you want to throw a vote for actual fluency, I'll definitely definitely love you for it. And it an easy link for the vote is if you go to actual fluency.com vote. And uh I'll greatly appreciate it. And actual fluency in in advantage of being with A, it it is at the top of the list. So hopefully that's uh telling more than just the alphabetic value of the name.
The other announcement that I had was that Italki, my favorite tutoring platform where I'm tutoring people in in Danish. I'm actually about to do uh some tutoring sessions in Russian. I just need to find out who exactly to uh to choose. So if you have any experience with any Russian teachers on Italki, uh preferably professional teachers, then do uh throw a comment below or send me an email via the contact page on the actualfluency.com. The uh the promotion that run running for the end of May until the end of May is that you can get free 100 credits just by signing up. And the way you do it is you just go to actualfluency.com Italki. And if you're a new user, you will be credited 100 free credits. And uh I think I'm might be getting something as well. I don't know if I get anything. But anyway, uh that's not the point. The point is that you get a free 100 credits and you can actually, you know, for most languages, 100 credits is more than enough to book a session with. So it's a free one-hour session with a community teacher on Italki, which I think is is a very good promotion. And uh so obviously, they're doing it to attract new users and as a as a teacher on there or tutor if you prefer. I can definitely uh recommend it. It's a very good site and you can definitely learn a lot if you allow it. So have 100 free credits uh by using the URL actualfluency.com Italki.
And um that's about it. That's all the admin for today. And and now it's on to the main event, which is the uh interview with Mr. Olly Richards. And in the interview, I'm just going to give a little warning or perhaps a heads up if you prefer. Uh we're talking a lot about Asian languages because uh my fascination with Olly was that he learned Japanese and Chinese, which for Westerners, I mean, he's from England and I'm from Denmark. So, for the for the people around those regions, those would be seen as as perhaps some of the most dangerous uh advanced language to learn. So that's why we're going into a lot of detail about this. And I'm, you know, I don't know anything about these languages. So I hope that by me asking these kind of beginner-ish questions to Olly that you might also find them useful if you plan to study Chinese or indeed Japanese or a similar language even. So, that's all I want to say. I just want to uh enjoy the enjoy the uh interview with Olly Richards and I'll see you later.
All right. Today I'm excited to welcome onto the show Mr. Olly Richards. Olly is the man behind I will teach you a language.com and speaks seven languages. He has top advice on language learning and shares his experiences through writing on his blog and videos on his YouTube channel. Welcome to the show, Olly. How are you today?
Hey Kris. Thanks very much. Very pleased to be here.
Fantastic. And Olly, I've given the listeners a a brief introduction of yourself, but maybe you just want to take a minute so they can get to know you a little bit better on how you got started with all this language learning?
Yeah, sure. Okay. Well, um I guess the first thing to say is that uh I really started um well, the first time I learned any languages was at school. I did uh French and German for a couple of years at uh secondary school. Um high school for those that are used in the in the in the States. And uh I was, you know, pretty pretty average student. I learned a few bits and pieces but you know, you you come out of school and you can't really speak much. So you know, I got to I was a sort of 18, 19 and uh I didn't have any languages, any language skills to speak of.
Um, and it all sort of started when uh I decided I did my first year at uh at university and I was studying jazz piano, which was really cool and a lot of fun. And uh, but after a year, I decided to take some time out because I wanted to um I actually wanted to spend a year just practicing piano and I wanted to become really, really good. Um, but I was sort of knocked for six a little bit because my girlfriend at the time uh decided we should break up. And that sort of threw me into this big downward spiral and uh, and I ended up not being able to do any any practice and not focus on the music. And I ended up getting a job in a cafe in Central London. And I and then uh, so I was sort of sitting there serving serving coffee all day. But I was surrounded by um people from all over the place. People from Sweden and from uh, from Italy, from Spain, from France. And so I just for the first time came into contact with uh, with people um who who weren't from the UK. And so that sort of opened up my eyes to the big wide world, if you like. And um, that was the point where I started becoming interested in in actually, you know, I started to think how cool would it be if I could actually talk to talk to this person in uh, in Spanish or you know, that girl in in French. Right. And um, and so that's that's sort of when it started and then after that I I kind of went on various language learning missions and uh, and um, sort of picked up languages one after the other.
Snowball off that initial success.
Yeah, exactly.
But but did you at the time when you were working in the cafe and you and you spoke basically only one language, did did you consider it almost impossible the idea of learning a new language or or or had you had any exposure to the you know, the polyglot world or, you know, anyone who would be multilingual enough for you to see it as a realistic opportunity?
Well, the thing is that when you I mean, I I didn't well, your first well, your first point was about did I think it was impossible? And no, I didn't. Um, I I always I've always had a sort of can do attitude to stuff. I think and I I I don't think anything is impossible. I've never never really have. That's not to say that I knew how to do it or how to go about it. But I but I knew that I would be able to if I set my mind to it.
Um, but the other thing is, you know, when you when you meet people, especially from um, from Scandinavia, uh, you know, people who a lot of the sort of Swedish guys that I met, they spoke perfect English. Completely flawless. And you know, the Italian girl spoke Spanish and the the the French girl spoke German and and so you know, you meet these people and you realize look a lot of people out there speak plenty of languages and they've just grown up that way. So um, so you know, and they're just normal people. Just that they've grown up in a in an environment where um, another language is not seen as such a sort of foreign concept like it is in the UK. It's just a natural.
So it was your exposure to to the foreign cultures that kind of uh, inspired you. And the reason I I say this is of course because I I think a lot of people around the world um, who might be new to learning languages might see it as a very, very difficult task. And that isn't to say that it's easy, but by no means of the imagination. But it's very hard to begin learning a language if you believe that it's impossible. Wouldn't you say so?
Well, yeah, I mean, but I think in that sense, you can apply that to to anything, you know, whether you want to build a business or whether you want to learn a language or become a become an athlete, you know, it all start it all starts from the mindset. You've got to believe it's possible and you have to you have to have the desire to do it.
Um, and then after that it's just a it's just a case of taking one step at a time and keeping that motivation there. You know, that's that's really what it comes down to, I think. You know, if I if I find myself one day not motivated to keep on learning a language, that's it for me, you know, it's that's nothing I can do to to carry on. This is game over.
So which one did you uh, did you start out with? Was that French or?
Yeah, it was French. I um, well, I mean, when I was I was working in that cafe only for a couple of months and I sort of I dabbled in a bit of French and a bit of Italian but not not really seriously. I didn't really know what I was doing.
But after a few months, I actually quit and bought I I bought a one way ticket to Paris. I had a bit of cash. I had my student loan from the second year you see. So I uh I shouldn't have had it but I did. So I thought, you know, let's go and spend it. So I jumped on the Eurostar. I went to Paris. And um, I said right, I'm going to see what happens here. And um, I ended up blagging my way into a a job after a few weeks in Paris. Um, and it was a job where I had to I was working in a in a youth hostel. And uh, so I had to use English a lot but I also obviously had a lot of French customers in. So I kind of threw myself into that job. And um, had had to learn French. I had no no option at that point. Uh, which is kind of crazy looking back on it. And I wouldn't do that now.
Yeah.
Um, 15 years later, you know, but I um, I did at the time. I guess I I guess, you know, when when you're when you're that age, you just don't really care that much, do you? So. But again, I think that it just it does show that I was I really wanted it, you know.
Right. You didn't go to to Paris, which is obviously a big tourist location and just found yourself in kind of an English bubble or something. You actually threw yourself in a place, like in a in a reception desk where lots of lots of French people came through. So you?
Yeah, well, I did have a I did have something of an of an English bubble. I mean, I actually I was actually staying staying in a youth hostel at the time. So I was surrounded by by tourists actually.
But you know, over time that that started to um to to dissipate a bit and I started to, you know, make French friends and you know, ended up with a with a French girlfriend. And so, you know, bit by bit that um, that, you know, I I started to become a slightly more French
Right.
French life, you know.
But but it was, you know, I I don't know if you want to make any uh general conclusions about immersion but but what do you think about, you know, living abroad compared to studying a language from home? I know you've done both. What are the what do you think is it is it as good as as one would expect or or can you sort of mimic the experience at home as well and and achieve good results there too?
Well, I mean, if if the question is can you achieve good results at home without living without being immersed in the culture, then absolutely.
How important is it, I guess, is the is the is the big question. How important is it to be in the country when you're learning a language?
Well, it's an interesting question because I think most people probably don't have a choice. You know, asking that question a way, in a way is like saying you know, for people who who who do live at home and don't live abroad, um, you know, it it's kind of a of a of a non-starter really because most people can't just pick up and and move. move abroad. I mean, so it's it's absolutely not necessary.
Um, but obviously if you if you do live in the country where the language is spoken, you've got you've got I think extra you've got more opportunities. But I think, you know, it's important to to to realize that probably, you know, the the majority of people that do go and live abroad uh, don't really get very far in that in that language. It's not a given at all. And um, you know, everywhere I've I've I've lived abroad, I've been been surrounded by people uh, the majority of whom don't speak the local language. So you know, it's certainly not a case of if you live abroad, that's it, you're going to become fluent in
Right.
in two weeks. You've got to put in all the work. Right. And and if you do what most what a lot of people do and fall into a kind of expat bubble, in a way, that's much harder because you can you you can start to get frustrated. A lot of people in Japan, for example, where I was for a few years, um, find themselves in an expat bubble and then and it's difficult to break out. And then so you know, they they build this they see Japanese people and uh, and the the prospect of talking with Japanese people and practicing their Japanese, it starts to become this massive thing in their head and
Right.
and it just becomes something that can be quite difficult to to get over. So I mean, if you, but then again, if you do live in the country and you've got some good study habits and you've and you are actively trying to learn the language, then of course you do have extra benefits. I mean, you're surrounded by the language every day. You've got more people to practice with. Uh, you know, it's real interaction with people as opposed to, I don't know, learning on on on Skype or something.
Right.
So, there are differences and but it that is really important, I think that that's not used as an excuse not to get started. That's the most important thing.
Yeah, it was a bit of a leading question I guess in in that I I think that when you're learning a language from home, you know, you can get very far and because you're you kind of dedicated to learning the language and you you you take on the task, it's it's a lot different mentality than being in the country and you're kind of like, oh, well, I'm here and I'm listening to the language. So I must be learning it, right? You know, a good learner at home probably gets infinitely more done than a bad learner in the country.
Yeah, yeah, I think that's absolutely right. And I've seen I've seen cases of both happening. Uh, and I've been guilty of that myself, you know, when I went to Japan, uh, for the first time, I was um, well, I've only been once, but when I went to actually live there, I didn't do much in the first year, you know. Right.
Um, language learning wasn't really top of my agenda. I'd started a new job and I was focused on on living and and and doing my job and uh, and I didn't focus on the language. And I I I spent the first first year not really having any proper study routine. And I I picked up a load of language a load of vocabulary and uh, functional language along the way. But I really didn't make a great deal of progress in that first year. So, so, you know, it just just goes to show it's not it's not all it's cracked up to be. Right. Broad and it's not without its challenges.
Right. And uh, obviously, you know, you've learned a a lot of great languages, but for me, the the two that kind of stand out a little bit are the Japanese and the the Cantonese. Uh, what drew you to these uh, these Asian languages?
Uh, well, in in Japan, it was purely because I was living there. Right. So I wanted to learn it.
So you went to Japan before you started learning the language?
Yeah, I I didn't know any Japanese. Right. I mean, I think I'd learned to I'd learned to write, I'd learned the hiragana alphabet and uh, I tried to learn katakana but it wouldn't really stick because they're fairly similar. Um, but essentially not I didn't I knew knew nothing. And um, and I mean I did want to go to Japan and I and I very I was really uh, into Japanese culture. Um, you know, and I was the prospect of going to Japan was was cool. I was excited by it. So that obviously helped.
Um, and then in terms of Cantonese, it's funny because I I've been to Hong Kong a few a couple of times on holiday and uh, I have some friends from Hong Kong. And and it's, you know, and I've always enjoyed watching, you know, sort of uh, Bruce Lee and all these martial arts movies. So it was a culture that kind of kind of just started growing up on me. I just started developing an interest. Just like everyone does, you know, one language or another. And um, and I just it just got to a point where I said, you know what? I want a new challenge. Um, let's let's let's try Cantonese. And um, so yeah, that was really the first time that I tackled a language that I really had not much uh, involvement in and wasn't living there and didn't have any friends around me who were speaking it. So that was that was that was my first sort of big outsider language learning experience.
What kind of difficulties did you find when learning Cantonese? How fa how how long have you been learning it for now?
Uh, less than a year. Probably about uh, getting on for nine months now. Eight, nine months.
I saw you.
And it hasn't been it hasn't been intensive at all. I've been uh, doing it fairly I've been trying to keep it consistent but not really uh, I haven't been going at it full on.
Right. That's the important bit, isn't it, anyway? I I mean, that's my personal opinion is that it's better to do something every day for a small amount of time than, you know, doing something sporadically once a week or something for a longer amount of time.
Yeah, and uh, because it's it's more I mean, Cantonese for me has been more of a more of a hobby than than other languages. So I don't I'm not in any great rush to No. learn it. So I'm sort of happy to um, happy to just kind of enjoy the process. Whereas with Japanese, I mean, because I was in Japan, I was, you know, I had that that incentive to to get off my ass and actually do the work, you know. I don't have
More intensive.
Yeah. I don't have that now but it's it's it's more enjoyable in a way because I can just enjoy the enjoy the process and uh,
Yeah.
enjoy spending time with the language.
Yeah, I saw your I saw some of your uh, status update videos for for fun. I I I looked at the, you know, the month one and then I looked at month two and three and four. And it seemed like you you made quite rapid progress there. You you had some conversations and I mean, yeah, you had some, you know, pauses here and there and stumbles but do you feel that your experience from learning all the other languages is kind of speeding up the process at this point even at such a difficult language as Cantonese?
Um, yeah. I don't I mean, honestly, it's difficult to say. I I don't think that the uh, the language itself is made any easier by the other languages I've learned because um, Cantonese is is like no other language I've ever at all. It's I mean, I I I Japanese has some bearing on it. Um, in that I know some of the Chinese characters. But it's very different. So I've really been starting from from scratch with the language.
But what has had a a big a big bearing is just the kind of uh, having been through the the learning process so many times. Right. I I didn't necessarily realize this myself. But I mean, I think when I when I kind of get get get comments and questions from people on my on my blog, I I I sort of start to to realize where a lot of the problems that people have lie and a lot of the time it's not really knowing what to expect from the learning process. And and I think now what I realized that with Cantonese, you know, being such a difficult language, the big advantage that I brought to the table was that I knew what to expect.
Right.
So, when I was trying to speak and it was really hard, it didn't bother me that much. When I was trying to learn this new vocabulary and there was just so much to learn and I didn't know how I was going to learn it. I didn't get too frustrated because I knew that's the process that you've got to go through.
Right.
Um, and so that in that sense it was it was more manageable.
That was the experience of the previous languages, not so much the actual languages, it's more the process that helped you uh for Cantonese.
Yeah, because I mean I I don't really believe that any, I don't know, it depends where you where you're coming from and what your mother tongue is, but I don't think that objectively there is much difference. I mean when people when people say, you know, this language is harder than that or that language is harder than the other, I it's, you know, it's a false dichotomy really because all right, Cantonese may be harder than uh, than French for an English speaker.
Um, but it's, you know, the motivation that you bring and your passion for learning is is infinitely more important than um, than the the content of the language that you that needs to be learned.
That's that's good. And if you if you have any, do you have any specific advice for people who are looking to learn well, let's say Cantonese first but also Japanese uh coming back to that before they start?
Um, there's a lot it sort of depends what what aspect you want to focus on. But I mean, I think the thing is really, you've got to expect it to take time.
Right.
I mean, don't don't go in there thinking, um, I'm going to, you know, I've got to be fluent in three months or six months or whatever. It's not going to happen. Right. Um, you So just the realization that it's going to take time. Right. Right straight away, that relieves the pressure a little bit. You know, you can afford to make mistakes. You can afford not to be perfect. You can afford not to not to um, you know, remember all this vocabulary from the start.
So I think, you know, Asian languages do tend to be tough for for for Westerners and and yeah, I'd I'd say the most important mindset is just not to expect too much from the start and just
Right.
be prepared to uh, for it to take time.
Excellent. And and I mean, I I haven't had any experience with with Asian languages. So, so you can help me out here as well, but what is your um, general wisdom when talking about the scripts? Because I've heard a lot of people recommend that you learn the oral language first before you start looking at the at the characters. Is that do you agree with that or do you have another approach to to this?
It's I've seen it argued very convincingly uh, both ways. And um, I think I wouldn't like I wouldn't like to say which is better, whether you should learn the script uh, at the start or or whether you should ignore the script and just learn the language. But I think there are a few things to point out on that topic.
Um, the first one being that learning the script, uh, in a Chinese dialect, for example, or in the case of Japanese, the kanji, because they in the case of Japanese, the the hiragana and the katakana are fairly easy to learn, so you should definitely learn that straight away.
Right.
No no question because that's that's manageable and learnable in a weekend, if you really want to. So in the case of Japanese, we're talking about the kanji, the Chinese characters. And then in the case of obviously Mandarin or Cantonese, we're talking about, well, there's there is only, you know, the field of Chinese characters. Right.
So, um, you know, the thing about that is it's it's a massive task to learn Chinese characters. It it you can't underestimate the the size of the task. And so if you've only got a finite amount of time to study every day, then inevitably, that's going to take there's going to detract from the amount of time you've got to do other things.
Right.
Um, and so if you're sort of short on time and you still want to make progress with your speaking and you want to really be able to speak and that's that's the most important thing for you and you know, you're not necessarily looking to integrate into Chinese lifestyle. Then I think I mean, my personal approach is is not to do much with um, Chinese characters. Right.
I mean, I I've learned quite a lot in quite a few in Japan and um, I've obviously bought some of those with me to to Cantonese. Uh, but I've I yeah, I've I've personally I've personally try again. Personally, I've uh, I've avoided learning spending a lot of time learning Chinese characters because I just feel that I can get a lot more uh, benefit from focusing on on on on vocabulary and and and speaking in particular because that's my aim.
Right.
So I think, um, it really comes down to you know, understanding how long it's going to take. How much time it's going to take to learn Chinese characters. And then making that call for yourself, you know, whether or not you want to um, you want to spend that time. All things being equal, then yeah, learn the characters from the beginning, but you know, all things are never equal. So,
Of course.
So that's just the choice that has to be made, I think.
And and again, reiterating that you need to find your focus. I mean, if you want to learn it just to speak it casually and, you know, in conversation, then maybe the characters is not that big of a focus for you, but if you want the full package and you want and you're okay with spending relatively large amount of time on it, then go ahead and do it. But you but as you say, it has to fit with your goals.
Yeah, exactly. And I I really don't think you can make a judgment either way because I've I've heard from people who have said I mean one one guy uh, I think he watched one of my Cantonese videos. It was early on, I think two or three months and he said, man, I've been living in China for two years and and I I focused on learning Chinese characters but I still I can't speak
Wow, yeah.
as well as you. And not, you know, not that I was speaking very well at all at that stage but the point is, you know, there's a case in point of someone who has spent a lot of time focusing on Chinese characters and as a result hasn't got very far in in his speaking.
His spoken is suffering, yeah.
Yeah, so I mean, who knows his particular situation. I mean, that might not apply to everybody but but you know, that's uh, it's it's it's certainly a risk and something you've got to you've got to consider.
Right. If I mean, again, I I don't know anything about this. Can you just briefly give uh a difference between Chinese characters and the Japanese characters for somebody who doesn't know anything about it because it seems like you say, well, Japanese you should definitely do it. Chinese I would consider not doing it. But why is it that there such a difference there? Can you give me the one year the crash course.
Yeah, sure. Let me let me clarify then. So in Japanese you've got three alphabets. You've got the hiragana uh and katakana which are phonetic alphabets with I think it's 50 around about 50 50 characters in each one.
Uh-huh.
And so any any word in Japanese you can write in either hiragana or katakana.
Oh, okay.
It's phonetic.
So that's like an alphabet basically.
It's like an alphabet, except, um, a large amount of words, I'd say the majority of words are not written in hiragana or katakana, but they're written in Chinese characters.
Right.
Which is the third alphabet if you like in Japanese, except you know, you need to learn around about uh, 2,000 of those Chinese characters.
Right.
Uh, to be uh, to be fluent according to the definition of the Japanese government. It's 9 1,981 uh, Chinese characters that are suggested for daily use. Wow.
Wow.
Uh it was I think the number might have changed slightly now, but it's but that's that's the ballpark figure. And so uh, so yeah, that's the real challenge in Japanese is to um, is to learn those.
Right.
those 2,000 uh, kanji. Now in terms of in terms of Chinese, you've got uh, as far as I know. I'm no expert on this but you've got two two different sets of Chinese characters in Chinese. You've got um, you've got simplified and traditional.
Uh-huh.
Um, now simplified Chinese characters are what is used in Mandarin in the mainland. And uh, they are similar to the kind of the Chinese characters you'd get in Japan, but they've been simplified in order to make them more easy to learn, for easier to learn. Um, and they originally came from traditional Chinese characters, which is what they still use in Hong Kong and I think in Taiwan as well.
Uh-huh.
And they're much more complicated. They've got many more strokes and they're more uh, they're more old school beautiful uh, characters.
Right.
Um, so is that is that Yeah, that's that that explains it. How do you know how many there are of those or is that a completely unknown scale?
How many are those?
I've heard various numbers but you're talking in the five figures. It's at least 10 10,000 of them.
Wow.
Yeah, that's why I'm saying you really can't underestimate the size of that.
Right. And I'm imagining just the memory for for Western, so to speak, it's like, you know, you can remember remember an alphabet of say 20 20, 30, 40 characters but remembering thousands of thousands of pictures. It which is essentially is, is it's just it's a mind-boggling thing and for anyone who's done it, I I really uh, can't describe how how uh, how envious I am of that feet because that is incredible.
Yeah, although just I mean just on that point, that's not to say that every single you have to learn every single character new because what what you find is the more that you learn, the easier it gets because every character is composed of of uh, different parts. So you have a lot of kind of base uh, sort of fundamental characters and then a lot of the more complicated characters are just composites of those more simple uh, characters. So, uh, you know, it does actually definitely get easier the more that you learn.
Right. That's that's always a positive, I would say.
Well, yeah, you got you got to look for the positive. Exactly. Otherwise, you're never going to do it.
So would you would you recommend people learning uh Cantonese or should they learn Mandarin or one of the others? What what are the reasons for learning one over the other?
Uh, well, I that's very difficult to answer because I mean, I'd say if you're interested in it, then then learn it if you're not, then don't. Right. Uh, really. I mean, if you if it's purely I mean, I don't know why why one would learn a language without a particular interest in it. I I don't know.
Well, maybe they just want to learn Chinese and they don't know there's two different Chinese.
Yeah. Uh I guess, well, you've got to think about uh, if you plan on using it then I guess it's I would you would you plan on going to Hong Kong? Uh, where, you know, where do you see yourself spending spending the most time? Right. Um,
Are they similar? I mean, how I'm yeah, of course they're similar, but how similar are they? I guess is my question because, you know, I'm from Denmark and we have the similarity between Norway and Norwegian and Swedish. Is is there a similar relationship in Cantonese and Mandarin where they have the same kind of structure and use different words?
Oh, yeah. Yeah, absolutely. Because I mean, the Cantonese is a funny one because uh, it Cantonese has no proper written language. Uh, Cantonese is a spoken dialect. And so the words are different from from China. However, you would write them in the same way. So a Chinese someone from mainland China can read uh, things that are written down in Hong Kong because in Hong Kong, you write Cantonese down using traditional Chinese, not Cantonese.
Right.
And so the grammar structure of of the of the of Mandarin and Cantonese are, you know, virtually identical as far as I'm aware. Um, what differs is when you speak Cantonese, uh, you use different words.
Right.
So, you know, you're going to get a word which written down, you would pronounce it one way, but then when you speak it, you pronounce it another way.
Wow.
So yeah, it's it's uh, it's not straightforward. That's interesting.
That's interesting. I I mean just even the concept is a little bit it's quite foreign to me that you can have a different spoken and written language existing at the same time.
Yeah, I mean, I think a good analogy is if you think of, you know, street language in uh, I mean, I I can only really think of the UK as an example if you think of something like someone in uh, walking down the street in East London. Right. The way he's going to talk, uh, you know, you would never write that down if you were writing a kind of uh, a serious piece of of writing. No. That's not how you write. So the way that you that that you speak on the street and the way that you write in the proper language, they're they're different. Um, so you can kind of see it that draw that that kind of analogy.
Right. And um, going back a little bit to uh you briefly mentioned uh motivation. Um, what do you do to keep motivated during a, let's say, one of your language missions?
Um, it's always different for me to be honest. Um, and uh, Cantonese has been a different experience because like I say, I'm not surrounded by uh, by the people or the culture. So, um, certainly in the past, when I've started to learn a language, it's always been because I've got a very real tangible reason for learning that language. So, with with French, I was in I was living in France. Um, I when I was in France, I learned Italian because I wanted to go to to Italy. And then I went to Italy. And then when I went back to the UK, I had a Spanish friend, so I learned Spanish. And um, so I you know, I motivation has never really been a problem for me because I'm motivated by the people around me and the um, you know, the prospect of being able to speak and communicate with other people in their language. You know, assuming it's people that I like and people who are around me, that's that's really all the uh, all the motivation I I I've needed to have.
Um, but in Cantonese, it's different because uh, you know, like I said, I'm I'm pretty isolated here where I am now in in in Qatar. And um, it's been difficult to stay motivated because um, you know, I got no one to speak to. And um, it really comes down to for me at the moment in this current um, language that I'm trying to learn, it comes down to having a routine. Right. And just doing it every day.
Well, that that might be a good segue into uh my next question uh one of the questions I I like to ask everyone who comes on is if you had to learn a new foreign language from scratch to starting tomorrow. What kind of routines and methods would you would you work on? And and of course, this is uh the concise version uh if you if you had to uh talk about every single detail, you could probably spend two or three episodes, but you know, kind of an overview of of of of the language learning method that you've and I I use the word method carefully here. I just mean a collection of ideas. Um, that you've kind of assimilated from all your experiences of of learning these different languages.
Yeah, well I I could I could give you a fairly realistic example actually because I I've recently found out that I'm I'm going to be moving to uh, to to to Egypt. And uh, so I I I want to learn Arabic. Uh, I know some Arabic already. Um, I last year, I I I took some lessons and I I learned to read and write. Um, but in terms of kind of conversational ability, I'm you know, for all intents and purposes, I'm I'm at zero. Okay. So it's something that I'm actually, you know, gearing up for right now. So, um, it's something I'm I'm going to have to do in the in the in the coming months.
So, you know, the sort of back of a napkin version is, um, I will start by getting hold of a textbook that I like. I don't know which one yet for Arabic. Um, I quite like the teach yourself series. Uh, a lot of people use Assimil. I'm going to get one of those and I'm going to work through it. Yeah. Um, quite systematically. And at the same time, I'm going to try and get hold of some some TV or some some some movies in Arabic, in Egyptian Arabic that I like and I'm going to start watching them a lot in my free time. Right.
Uh with the the textbook I'm going to focus um on two things. Firstly on vocabulary. I'm going to look at um, as I study go through the lessons and study, I'm going to isolate words and phrases that I think are going to be very useful and I'm going to make an effort to learn those. And then the second thing is I'm going to concentrate on the audio that comes with the book. And I'm going to spend a lot of time every day just listening to the audio and reading following it through with the text. Right. Listening and reading, listening and reading, listening and reading. And I'm going to do that for a good couple of months to get that real solid foundation.
And at that point then I'll start uh, I'll start speaking more. I mean, that's not to say I won't speak before that, but I mean I'll start having creating structured opportunities to speak. So I'll start meeting with a language partner two or three times a week, uh, maybe for just half an hour. And then just speaking with that person two or three times a week and getting feedback from them on uh, on on my dreadful Arabic. And um, and then basically then just repeat all of the above.
Right. And and you and you talked about the importance of having a routine. So would you have would you have like a to-do list or a calendar where you put in 50 minutes of this, then that or how structured are you when it comes to the organization of it?
Yeah, I I'm I'm not a particularly disciplined person. Uh, which is my which is my major downfall in all areas of my life. Right. Not just language learning. Uh, and I have trouble. To be honest, I have real trouble with traditional goal setting, uh, setting a routine, things like this. I just I'm too impatient. I'm too uh, you know, Right. I just I just don't have that that sticking power.
So, I I take an approach which is something that I call uh, I've called uh, sprints. And the idea of a sprint is that you rather than sort of setting your your goals and then breaking them down into sub goals and then uh, you know, individual things. I tend to just focus on one thing and I just go all out with that one thing. All right. For a certain period of time. Um, so the idea is that you're just you're kind of sprinting in one direction for as long as you can for as long as you you, you know, you want to. Right.
So, for example, I might take um, I might say right, I'm starting Arabic so I'm going to really tackle this textbook. I've got this textbook. I know that I need to learn some of the basics inside this textbook. So I'm just going to go health for leather at this textbook for um, for I know an hour a day, perhaps. And I'm just going to keep doing that until I run out of steam. Right. Um, and you know, I've found in the past that that time frame is typically about three weeks. After three weeks I start to get bored and I want to change. Right.
And then you find alternatives.
Yeah, and then I find something else. I mean, I find something else that I know is going to be helpful and that I need. And I will then go at that all in for another another period of time.
And I found that the the major advantage of doing this is that you just go really into depth with stuff. Right. Um, and if you try to do three or four things at the same time every day, you're kind of jumping from one thing to the next and you don't really get, you know, deep inside that thing. So, um, you know, I I found that that focus and concentration on one thing alone. It sort of pushes your brain further than it would otherwise go. And that I find, you know, really helps to to to solidify uh, what you're doing.
Right. And you're obviously you're obviously have a musical background as well. Do you incorporate that in in when you're learning a new language, finding some local music or
Uh, no, not explicitly. I mean, I I've found music in the past, but I, you know, I uh, it's not something that I consciously do.
It's an interesting concept, you know, uh, Suzanna Serebsky talks about it in her book, you know, uh, learning languages through music. And uh, I I don't do it but maybe when you had that musical background, maybe you you had uh an easier time of of using the concept.
Well, yeah, I mean let me caveat that by saying that actually when I learned Portuguese, uh, I actually I learned Portuguese entirely through music. Oh, there you go. At the beginning. It's just that I mean, I so what I did is I sat in my room and I played I learned the words to all these bossa nova songs and learned to play them on the guitar and sing them at the same time. But the thing about that is I I I'm crazy about Brazilian music. I love Brazilian music. So I I could and I did do that for for for hours on end. You know, weeks, months, days uh, just kept on going.
But I don't think I could do that with Arabic, for example, because I don't particularly like Arabic music. It's not my thing. And likewise, you know, I'm not I didn't do that with J-pop either. Japan J-pop drives me crazy. So, so, you know, if you happen to love the music of the language that you're learning, then yes, absolutely go for it. But um, one of the uh, disadvantages of um, being a musician is that you get quite picky about the kind of music you listen to. So uh, yeah, I'm a bit fussy in that in that sense.
Well, that makes sense. Um, okay. So, last uh, question about language learning here is uh, or maybe not a question but more of a realization that when you learn a lot of languages and you move from one to the next and obviously you you don't live in a country where every single language is spoken daily. Um, do you suffer from kind of language deterioration and do you have any tools or things you do to try and combat that?
Uh, yes is the answer. I mean, the first part I do suffer from language deterioration definitely. I mean, my my French, for example, used to be great when I was in in Paris. Um, and you know, whilst I still understand everything, uh, I can't speak it particularly well anymore. Um, or certainly not as well as I as I used to. And uh, you know, my Japanese, I I've been out of Japan now for a year and a half and I haven't used my Japanese. So, I I I notice myself getting less sharp.
Right.
Um, the thing is for me that I really don't treat um, language language learning for me is not a sort of academic exercise that I do for the sake of it. It's really it's it's something that I almost feel like I have to do because of my surroundings. Um, so, you know, when I was in Japan, I just I just had to learn Japanese. I mean, for me, there's no choice. I I felt like I had to do it. And so for me the whole the whole reason I'm learning the language is because of the either the environment that I'm in or or the people that I'm with. And so if I if I move away from that environment, I don't force myself to to keep to keep learning or to keep speaking the language. I mean, I I might want to. I've I've been, you know, for example, been watching a lot of Japanese TV recently because I because I really like it. But basically I stop really trying when my motivation to to speak it uh, disappears or if my environment changes. And so the natural consequence of that is that yeah, it does the languages do do deteriorate. Um, and so, you know, if if if I were to start speaking French right now, I'd have a I'd I'd struggle.
Right.
But in a way, I don't really care because I know that if I were if I went to France and I spent a couple of weeks there, I know it would all come back eventually.
It's not lost, it's the point, I guess.
Yeah, I mean, who knows? I mean, if I if I leave it too much longer, maybe it will be, but but I've it yeah, I just I just honestly, I don't really care whether Right. whether I lose it too much because I know I I will speak the language again at some point. But when I do it, it's because I when I do come to speak Spanish again, for example, regularly, it's because I'm going to be with my best my best friend in in uh, in in the Canary Islands and we're going to just speak Spanish for for for for two weeks non-stop. And okay, I'll be a bit rusty at the beginning, but um, it'll come back and I've got I've got confidence in that. And um, so it's it's not something that really uh, really keeps me up at night. But Right. obviously the you know, the the result of that is I I'm not I'm not someone who can necessarily speak okay, yeah, I mean, I've learned seven languages, but I can't necessarily speak all of those at the top of my game at any one point. Right. Um, like I know, I mean, I've seen, you know, there are some people out there, um, uh, Luca and and uh, Richard, for example, who speak, you know, over, you know, a dozen languages and they can do it all uh, at the same time, you know, incredibly high level. It's it's just it's it's mind-blowing. Yeah. Um, I it's not really uh, something that I'm that I'm really aiming for and uh, yeah, so I I I tend to take a very sort of natural approach to it and when I need it, I uh, I sort of dredge it out. Right. And uh, yeah.
And and the understand I guess an important point is also just because you can't speak it due to having not used it enough, this still you still understand pretty much the same level. I mean, that doesn't go away, does it?
It doesn't it does I haven't found it to go away. I mean, I mean, yeah, I mean, obviously, I probably don't understand 100% of what I would have done 10 years ago, but but I I guess I do tend to um, I do tend to to to watch stuff on TV or to listen to something in different languages from time to time. And that kind of acts as a as a booster. Right. But yeah, I mean, what what goes first is the speaking. Yeah. Without a doubt. That that, you know, if you don't speak for a for a while, that that disappears really quickly. And so I guess for someone who's maybe got got got one one main foreign language that they speak and they don't live who have been moved, you know, moved away and haven't got the opportunity to to speak that, then I think it just if you want to maintain it, then you've you've got to just take the the logical approach. You've just got to use it. You know, you have to you have to watch movies in the language. You have to read in the language. You have to schedule in opportunities to speak on Skype with people in the language. Right. Uh, if you don't want to lose it, that's what you've got to do.
Fantastic.
And um, yeah, obviously the, you know, the the result of that is I I'm not I'm not someone who can necessarily speak okay, yeah, I mean, I've learned seven languages, but I can't necessarily speak all of those at the top of my game at any one point. Right. Um, like I know, I mean, I've seen, you know, there are some people out there, um, uh, Luca and and uh, Richard, for example, who speak, you know, over, you know, a dozen languages and they can do it all uh, at the same time, you know, incredibly high level. It's it's just it's it's mind-blowing. Yeah. Um, I it's not really uh, something that I'm that I'm really aiming for and uh, yeah, so I I I tend to take a very sort of natural approach to it and when I need it, I uh, I sort of dredge it out. Right. And uh, yeah.
And um, that that that's pretty much it. If people want to find out more about you and or maybe you can talk about what what are you uh, what are you working on now if you have any stuff coming on to your blog or uh, where people can find you?
Yeah, well, I I um, I have been really, really uh, basically out of action for the last three or four months because I've been uh, working on finishing it my my my master's dissertation. And that's recently just been submitted and um, I'm yeah, it's it's it's amazing. I've finally got time again. Sweet.
So, I feel like I'm just getting started, um, uh, on the blog now recently. I've got time to write and I've got a lot of a lot of great things that I'm I'm sort of planning. I've got a list of about 30 30 articles that I want to write and they're all going to be coming up um, in the not too distant future. And yeah, that's all over at uh, I will teach you a language.com.
Excellent. And uh what a saying title, by the way.
Yeah. It's it's it's that's what it says on the tin, right?
Exactly. And I I want to thank you so much, Olly, for for coming on to the show and and and indeed making making the connection as I've been, you know, following you for you for a while. So it's it's very nice to put a you know, the direct live voice behind the the face with the guitar.
Yeah, well, thanks very much, Chris. It's been a real pleasure.
Yeah, likewise. See you later.
Okay, take care. Thanks for listening to the Actual Fluency Podcast. For more information, be sure to check out actualfluency.com. Until next time, enjoy learning and have a great day.